The Montana Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) Order shares similarities with the Advanced Healthcare Directive. Both documents allow individuals to make decisions about their healthcare in advance of a situation where they might not be able to express their wishes due to incapacity or illness. While the DNR specifically directs emergency healthcare providers not to perform CPR or other life-saving measures, an Advanced Healthcare Directive can include a broader range of instructions regarding end-of-life care, pain management, and other medical treatments or interventions the individual desires or wishes to avoid.
The POLST (Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment) form is another document akin to the Montana DNR. It is intended for seriously ill or frail individuals in detailing their preferences for life-sustaining treatments, including CPR. Both POLST and DNR are actionable medical orders; however, POLST encompasses a wider array of medical directives, not just decisions about resuscitation, making it a comprehensive planning tool for individuals in declining health or with chronic conditions.
Living Wills bear resemblance to the DNR order in that they facilitate pre-made decisions concerning one’s end-of-life care. However, unlike a DNR order, which is strictly focused on the moment of cardiac or respiratory failure, Living Wills cover a broader spectrum of medical decisions, such as the refusal of ventilator support, artificial nutrition, and hydration among others. Both documents serve as a means to uphold the patient’s autonomy by respecting their healthcare wishes when they cannot voice them themselves.
The Medical Power of Attorney (POA) document, while distinct, shares a common purpose with the DNR order. The Medical POA designates an agent to make healthcare decisions on behalf of the individual, should they become unable to do so. Unlike the DNR, which is a specific medical order, the Medical POA covers a wide range of medical decisions, providing a delegated person the authority to interpret and implement the patient's wishes regarding treatments, including the decision to forgo resuscitative efforts if aligned with the patient's known desires.
The Five Wishes Document, an all-encompassing advance directive, intersects with the purpose of the Montana DNR in several ways. It allows individuals to detail their personal, emotional, and spiritual needs in addition to medical wishes at the end of life, encompassing the directive found in a DNR. While the DNR focuses solely on the act of resuscitation, the Five Wishes document addresses a wider scope, including who makes care decisions when the patient cannot, the kind of medical treatment they want or don't want, how comfortable they wish to be, how they want people to treat them, and what they want their loved ones to know.
A Healthcare Proxy is similar to a DNR in context but diverges in application. It provides the appointment of an individual to make healthcare decisions on behalf of the patient if they are incapable of making decisions themselves. While it does not contain specific medical orders like a DNR, it is instrumental in ensuring the patient’s healthcare preferences, including decisions about resuscitation, are respected. The designated proxy, therefore, plays a crucial role in advocating for the patient’s wishes regarding end-of-life care and treatment interventions.
Lastly, the Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Do Not Resuscitate Order aligns closely with the Montana DNR in both purpose and application. Specifically designed for emergency medical situations, this form instructs emergency personnel not to initiate CPR or other lifesaving treatments. While the Montana DNR is used broadly within healthcare facilities and among healthcare providers, the EMS DNR is particularly intended for use in situations outside of hospitals, such as at home or in the community, ensuring the individual’s wishes regarding resuscitation are honored in emergency scenarios.